When the brothers were growing up in Gallatin, James Franklin, eight years older than Isaac, took his sibling under his wing. In the library at Yale I did a bit more unearthing and found a travelogue by a man named Ethan Andrews, who happened to pass through Alexandria a year later and witness the organizing of an Armfield coffle. They were not handcuffed, although they may have been tied with rope. In place of towns were stands every 10 or 15 miles. His book was not much readit had a due-date notice from 50 years agobut in it Andrews described the scene as Armfield directed the loading for an enormous journey. A good lot for walking was a gang of enslaved men, women and children, possibly numbering in the hundreds, who could tolerate three months afoot in the summer heat. You dont know what they did. In Staunton, the Visitor Center. I was sold with a younger sisterBettie. That applies to Southern history, to slave history. Can you tell it in a way that is not going to injure my sensitivity? It was typical on the Slave Trail: People like Waller marched a coffle and sold one or two people along the way to pay the travel bills. At the same time, that doesnt mean that he didnt have bad habits, Thomson clarifies. I had plenty of money for the trip, he said. A lot of black people, she said, do not want to know about their ancestry. At the central square are the contradictions of a Deep South village, both of Wallers time and the present. Many things in the Old Testament are pretty barbaric, but they are part of our evolution.. Thomson is sensitive to the suggestion that the family took benefit from the industrial-scale cruelty of Franklin & Armfield. My name was then Hannah Person, it is now Hannah Cole. I work for the government, I go to church, have two kids, and I say this story is too painful. But the tourist money is fairly recent. We had a guy that doubled as a driver and supervised the warehouse. This sorting arrangement meant that it was more likely children would be sold from their parents. Our mission is to offer gracious hospitality while providing opportunities for connecting with God & community. Its been a long time. Ferrill and was brought to Mobile, Alabama at the age of 10 years. Among the people who lived in these parts was John Randolph, a congressman and a cousin of Thomas Jefferson. James Ware, Wallers broker, was having no luck selling the truncated coffle in Mississippi. After Duck River, in Tennessee, came the Keg Springs Stand. Enslaved persons--Correspondence. But until recently, the Slave Trail was buried in memory. Gangs of slaves were welcome if they slept in the field, far from business. Thats good. Born 50 miles that way, Radford for 20 years. The Club at Fairvue Plantation opened in 2004, and hundreds of houses sprang up on half-acre plots. Next door to it was another, the New Orleans Exchange. They had seen the money others were making by selling out and decided to do the same. Lived in Nantucket (??) The Civil War interrupted the fortunes of the southern plantation owners and the cottages acquired by them were taken back by John Armfield. Armfield has at least one direct black descendant, Rodney Williams, who wrote about his heritage which he said he discovered through DNA testing in an essay included in " Slavery's. Thomson brings out an article that he wrote some years ago for the GallatinExaminer. In my family, people looked after their slaves, he said. I do not approve of revisionist historians. At the peak of their business, the two men were moving roughly 1,000 people a year, historians said. My name was Mary, and I was nine years old when sold to a trader named Walker, who carried us to North Carolina. Along the way, the coffle met other slave gangs, construction crews rebuilding the Wagon Road, widening it to 22 feet and putting down gravel. Although the Historic New Orleans Collection is the citys most serious and extensive history center, it attracted few blacks until this year. A few people launch into stories about the brave Confederates. Cobwebs to the face, bugs buzzing, overhanging branches to duck. Map sources: Digital Scholarship Lab, University of Richmond; Edward Ball; Guilbert Gates; Dacus Thompson; Sonya Maynard, Art and Picture Collection, The New York Public Library, Library of Congress Rare Book and Special Collections, Mississippi Department of Archives and History, AP Photo/The Natchez Democrat, Ben Hillyer, Subscribe to Smithsonian magazine now for just $12. Waller and his gang reached the Valley Turnpike in October. They are great people. That was possible largely because of the traders willingness to be unusually cruel and heartless even for a business built around the sale of human beings as they committed atrocities they appeared to relish. When Delores McQuinn was growing up, her father told her a story about a search for the familys roots. She lives 25 miles from Gallatin, in a pretty brick, ranch-style house with white shutters. Nearly 450,000 people were uprooted and sent south from the state between 1810 and 1860. In 1833, the slave-trading firm of Franklin and Armfield was buying at least 1,000 people a year out of the Mid-Atlantic states and selling them in New Orleans and Natchez, where Isaac Franklin spent most of his time. When Franklin wed a rich socialite in 1839, he had been raping the same enslaved woman for about five years and had fathered a child with her, Rothman said. Put them all together, we are like a big sports team. Tell me, aint you my child whom I left on the road near Mr. Moores before the war? I broke down and began to cry. Thin and erect, a crease of a smile, vigorous dark eyes. . He regularly acts as a mediator with respect to family provision claims. Many of their descendants own the cottages today. The words Virginia Negroes signaled a kind of brand, Greenwald says. Can anyone inform me of the whereabouts of John Person, the son of Hannah Person, of Alexandria, Va., who belonged to Alexander Sancter? It would turn out to be four. We were handcuffed in pairs, with iron staples and bolts, recalled Charles Ball, who marched in several coffles before he escaped from slavery. She is a politician now, elected to the city council in the late 1990s and to the Virginia House of Delegates in 2009. The Quakers have largely gone, and there are still many fewer black people than back in Virginia, 100 miles east. On September 6, the gang was marching 50 miles southwest of Roanoke. Which means that Isaac Franklin was my great-great-great-great-uncle., It is an important gloss, as it turns out: You see, Thomson said, my forebear James Franklin was the family member who introduced Isaac Franklin to the slave business., Taking a seat in an armchair upholstered in wine-colored brocade, he picks up the story. Franklin worked with a few partners over the years but connected with his longest-lasting collaborator the man who became his closest friend, confidant and nephew by marriage in the early 1820s. Long stretches of U.S. 11 look much like the Valley Turnpike did during the 1830srolling fields, horses and cattle on hills. Many went without their parents, or spouses, or siblingsand some without their childrenwhom they were made to leave behind. Trailer-park childhood. I mean, just gung-ho., Thomson gets up and walks through the house, pointing out the ample Franklin memorabilia. One of them was led by a man named William Waller, who walked from Virginia to Louisiana in 1847 with 20 or more slaves. And there, in an accident hardly repeated by any of the million on the Slave Trail of Tears, he found his mother. Slave traders brought a banjo or two and demanded music. Near a school playground in the middle of Raymond, I find the Dabney family graveyard, surrounded by an iron fence. No. So it must be true. It was like that. Katrina was cataclysmic, and it changed the way people thought about our collective history, Greenwald says. He lives alone in a five-room cottage in a black section of town, away from the camera-ready center of Natchez. After Emancipation, now a freedman of about 20, Glenn remembered the name of his hometownRoxboro. I say, your great-great-grandparents were enslaved persons. Are we responsible for what the slave traders did? But Sarah seems happy.. As for Sarah and Indian, they had been taken from Sarahs husband and her mother. This story is your story as well as an African-American story. The paper lists peoples names, their color and place of origin. Born in North Carolina, he worked as a stagecoach driver before meeting Isaac Franklin and joining him in the business of selling enslaved men, women, and children for profit. My mother was sold from me: After slavery, the desperate search for loved ones in last seen ads. The two livery coats, big-buttoned and long-tailed, were worn by an enslaved carriage driver and a doorman. Among them were the field hand Nelson, plus his wife; a man called Piney Woods Dick and another nicknamed Runaway Boots. login . Why does no one know their names? The black churches picked it up. After an hour of this, the showing of the lively stock, the enslaved stood in rows on long overhanging porches. She points to a beautiful piece of silk printed with the sentence, Slaves must be cleared at the Customs House. Its a sign that probably hung in staterooms on steamships. A kind of check-your-luggage announcement. You would get paid $3 for 100 pounds of picking cottonthat is, if you were lucky to find a farmer who would employ you.. The turnpike ran farther west40 miles to Winchester, and then to the brow of the Blue Ridge Mountains. The children were asleep in some tents; and the males, in chains, were lying on the ground, in groups of about a dozen each. Meanwhile, the white menwere standing about with whips in their hands.. The St. Louis Hotel is one of several places that can be identified as once-upon-a-time slave-trading sites. He carries a poster, 4 by 6 feet, in the back of his red Nissan truck. Behind the men were the women and girls, another hundred. Multiply that by 200. Franklin developed a taste for the business and, after taking a brief break to fight in the War of 1812, dedicated himself to slave trading full-time. Franklin probably bought him there and brought him to Tennessee in the early 1830s. Franklin, who was approaching his 50s, was tired and didnt want to do it anymore, Rothman said. If you squinted, you could see pinholes in it. As the gang fell in, Armfield and his men made jokes, standing near, laughing and smoking cigars.. This seemed to be as much a part of Franklin and Armfields culture of business as, say, going to the bar after a successful court case might be the culture of a successful law firms business.. Isaac Franklin, Armfields partner, kept house in Louisiana, but his thoughts were often in Tennessee. They packed flatboats with whiskey, tobacco, cotton and hogs, floated them down to New Orleans, sold the goods on the levee, and then sold the boat, Thomson says. John Armfield, slave trader and businessman, descended from North Carolina Quakers who were Loyalists during the American Revolution. Ten years ago there was an old beer garden standing on this site, where whites watched football and drank, and there was a gravel lot where trucks were parked. The city bought the half-acre lot in 1999, thanks largely to his agitation. This movement lasted longer and grabbed up more people than any other migration in North America before 1900. I put the car on the shoulder and walk into the woods to find the real Natchez Trace. After the Civil War, it held on as a cotton plantation, and then became a horse farm. I made a vow that I was going to North Carolina and see my mother if she was still living. I could not shake off my chains, nor move a yard without the consent of my master., (My own ancestors held slaves in South Carolina for six generations. I make a first estimate: zero. Some museum curators know about it, too. Now those, gesturing at some more yellowed papers, are the worst for me, she says. Then the coffle, like a giant serpent, uncoiled onto Duke Street and marched west, out of town and into a momentous event, a blanked-out saga, an unremembered epic. The Natchez Trace Parkway, with asphalt flat like silk, now follows the old route. Before he married, Isaac had companions, some willing, some unwilling. There is no branch of trade, in this part of the country, more brisk and profitable than that of buying and selling negroes, a traveler named Estwick Evans wrote about Natchez in the early 19th century. It gave the Deep South a character it retains to this day; and it changed the slaves themselves, traumatizing uncountable families. It was bigger than the wagon-train migration to the West, beloved of American lore. The chain gang also has roots in the Slave Trail. Northern Shenandoah was wheat country then, with one in five people enslaved and hoeing in the fields. He had six plantations and 650 slaves.. Through it all, both regularly raped the women they bought and sold and joked about it in letters, a shared habit that deepened their friendship. A flatboat could float down the Mississippi to Natchez in two weeks. The slave trade was all Isaac Franklin ever knew. After the women came the big wagonssix or seven in all. But something happened early on, although it is not clear just what. The men dressed in navy blue suits with shiny brass buttonsas they marched singly and by twos and threes in a circle, wrote Felix Hadsell, a local man. In the 1830s, Armfield fulfilled his vow as the partner of . Human bondage began I dont know when, but early, thousands of years ago. The first thing that meets the eye in Thomsons house is a large portrait of Isaac Franklin. In 1835, it was 4,723. As the country marks the 400th anniversary of the arrival of the first enslaved Africans in Jamestown, Americans are being forced to confront the brutality of slavery and of the people who profited from it. Mystery solved, she says. Do you know anything about the chain gangs that streamed southwest through these parts? He takes a seat at his melodeon, a portable organ that dates from the 1850s, and plays a few bars of period-appropriate music. In 1833, he wrote the office back in Virginia about fancy girls he had on hand, and about one in particular whom he wanted. Scholars of slavery are quite familiar with the firm of Franklin & Armfield, which Isaac Franklin and John Armfield established in Alexandria, Virginia, in 1828. I wish to inquire for my relatives, whom I left in Virginia about 25 years ago. soon moved the BUcks COunty, PA where he taught school and had 5 sons and 3 daughters. Caravans like Armfields covered about 20 miles a day. Approaching the former Franklin house, I pass the golf course and clubhouse. After examining the people on display, a buyer would talk to a seller and negotiate. Though unsure what he wanted to do, Armfield was clear on what he didnt: He loathed farming. I dont feel anything per se, she says, benignly. Many of the cottages were later acquired by successful merchants and professionals from Nashville and other places in Middle Tennessee. As plantations talk more honestly about slavery, some visitors are pushing back, In surviving correspondence, they actually brag about raping enslaved people who theyve been processing through the firm, said Calvin Schermerhorn, a professor of history at Arizona State University. When Armfield turned up with his gang in Gallatin, he seems to have handed the group not to Isaac Franklin, but to Franklins nephew James Franklin. The letter was the first sign that I might be able to trace the route of one of the Franklin & Armfield caravans. The Armfield coffle of 1834 is better documented than most slave marches. He could write a letter.. I do not believe that black people were responsible for their own enslavement, or that African-Americans should be grateful for slavery because they are better off than West Africans, or that a black man was author of the slave system. Part of Virginias section of that highway is known as the Lee-Jackson Highway, a love note to Robert E. Lee and Stonewall Jackson, the two Confederate generals. No commands given by anyone, no noise about it, no talking in the ranks, no laughter or merriment, just marching, round and round. The way I see it, he says, there are a lot of people you have to bury to get rid of. Today a few of the plantations survive. Waller knew his family. Outside universities and museums, the story of the Slave Trail lives in shards, broken and scattered. 2023 Smithsonian Magazine He expected another month on the road. Franklin & Armfield put more people on the market than anyoneperhaps 25,000broke up the most families and made the most money. I had never seen so revolting a sight before, he said. Golden Plains (Plantation : Mississippi) The coffles followed the same routethrough Kingston, Crab Orchard, Monterey, Cookeville, Gordonsville, Lebanon and, finally, Nashville. The partners employed stringersheadhunters who worked on commissioncollecting enslaved people up and down the East Coast, knocking on doors, asking tobacco and rice planters whether they would sell. Red flags fluttered down the streets in Richmond, on Wall Street in Shockoe Bottom, she said. Fairvue was a working plantation, but it was also an announcement that the boy from Gallatin had returned to his humble roots in majesty. Sarah and Indian, the mother and daughter, wanted to be sold together. While enslaved people waited in Franklin and Armfields holding pen in Alexandria, the two men most likely adopted classic techniques employed by slave traders to enhance enslaved peoples salability, McInnis said. He called it Fairvue. His book, Slaves in the Family (1998) won the National Book Award and was a New York Times bestseller. A month ago the bridge was uncovered with a backhoe by a developer, Boxley says. As for the other half, they were probably herded onto steamboats and churned 260 miles south to New Orleans, where Isaac Franklin or one of his agents sold them, one or three or five at a time. In 1857 alone, the sale of people in Richmond amounted to $4 million, McInnis said. He was so smooth he managed to impress even a New England abolitionist who visited Alexandria in the 1830s. Starting in Nashville I drive down the parkway. We werent there. Are we accountable? Even while actively trading slaves, the two men enjoyed an excellent reputation and moved in top-tier social circles, according to Rothman. They were made to go, deported, you could say, having been sold. It never occurs to them to think slavery might be bad: Slavery is what made their society work, it made them rich, it was a given that that was what black people were for, Rothman said. Armfield then ordered the men in irons to get in the water. I joined fifty-one other slaves whom he had bought in Maryland. A padlock was added to the handcuffs, and the hasp of each padlock closed on a link in a chain 100 feet long. Historians know about the Slave Trail. In 1832, at age 43, supremely rich from 20 years as a long-distance trader, Franklin built a big house on 2,000 acres outside Gallatin. The family story is that after Uncle Isaac came back from service during the War of 1812, which sort of interrupted his career path, if you call it that, he was all for the slave business. Isaac Franklin and John Armfield first met in 1824, when Armfield seems to have been at loose ends. Not long ago I was reading some old letters at the library of the University of North Carolina, doing a little unearthing of my own. The trace was a 450-mile roadtrace being the colonial word for a native trail through forestand the only overland route from the plateau west of the Appalachian Range leading to the Gulf of Mexico. In Raymond, thanks to Thomas Dabney, Waller had gotten in touch with a slave seller named James Ware, a 42-year-old with Virginia roots. Your Privacy Rights They bought shoes for them, blankets for them, brought in doctors to treat them. Reading lights look like converted oil lamps. (Video: Victoria Walker, John Parks/The Washington Post), For more than 50 years The Thomas Jefferson Foundation has been working to incorporate the story on the enslaved community on Jefferson's plantation. At the time, John Armfield was lacking in purpose: Shiftless and footloose, he had recently been chased away from a county in North Carolina for fathering a child out of wedlock, Rothman said. On June 24, 1865, two months after the truce at Appomattox, in a Philadelphia newspaper called theChristian Recorder, she posted this: Information Wanted. I dont spare anything. A painting of the mansion at Fairvue.