fowler v board of education of lincoln countyfowler v board of education of lincoln county

There is conflicting testimony as to whether, or how much, nudity was seen by the students. In my view this case should be decided under the "mixed motive" analysis of Mt. They also found the movie objectionable because of its sexual content, vulgar language, and violence. Kolender v. Lawson, 461 U.S. 352, 357, 103 S.Ct. One particularly controversial segment of scenes is animated in which flowers appear on the screen, are transformed into the shape of male and female sex organs and then engage in an act of intercourse. It is undisputed that Fowler left the room several times while the movie was being shown, and that she was posting grades during the time she was present in the classroom. re-employment even in the absence of the protected conduct." Following this executive session, the board returned to open session and voted unanimously to terminate plaintiff's employment for insubordination and conduct unbecoming a teacher. Writing for the Court, Justice Harlan stated that "while the particular four-letter word being litigated here is perhaps more distasteful than most others of its genre, it is nevertheless often true that one man's vulgarity is another's lyric. Ms. Francisca Montoya is a lifelong resident of Maricopa County and advocate of public education. Fisher v. Snyder, 476375 (8th Cir. I agree with both of these findings. District Court Opinion at 23. 1980); Cary v. Board of Education, 598 F.2d 535, 539-42 (10th Cir. 126, 127, 70 L.Ed. Although Judge Peck's opinion concedes that "the school board clearly expressed displeasure with the anti-establishment focus of the film," he argues nonetheless that the board's "objections to the `immoral' content of the film were intertwined with constitutionally permissible objections to the film's above mentioned vulgarity and unsuitability for the student age group. Sterling, Ky., for defendants-appellants, cross-appellees. Because we conclude that plaintiff's discharge may be upheld under the charge of conduct unbecoming a teacher, we need not reach this issue. In the present case, we conclude that plaintiff's conduct, although not illegal, constituted serious misconduct. Rehearing Denied January 22, 1987. . Pink Floyd is the name of a popular rock group. Consequently, the focus of our inquiry is whether Fowler's conduct was constitutionally protected. 1969)). To the extent that the district court's finding of fact number 34 may be interpreted as a finding that the defendants objected to the film only on an ideological level, the finding is clearly erroneous. Accordingly, we conclude that the statute is not unconstitutionally vague as applied to Fowler's conduct. Jacqueline Fowler had worked in the Lincoln County, Ky., school system for 14 years when she was fired in July 1984 for insubordination and conduct unbecoming a teacher. For the reasons that follow, we vacate the judgment of the district court and dismiss plaintiff's action. 161.790(1), which proscribes conduct unbecoming a teacher, is unconstitutionally vague as applied to her conduct. Joint Appendix at 321. 693, 58 L.Ed.2d 619 (1979); Mt. 1976) (teacher could not successfully contend that "due and sufficient cause" standard did not give notice that improper conduct toward students would result in discipline); Kilpatrick v. Wright, 437 F. Supp. Consequently, it awarded her reinstatement, back pay with interest, reimbursement of funds necessary for her reinstatement with the Kentucky Teachers Retirement System, damages for emotional distress and damage to professional reputation, compensatory damages for costs incurred in seeking new employment, costs, and attorney's fees. The district court concluded that Fowler's conduct was protected by the First Amendment, and that she was discharged for exercising her constitutionally protected rights. The film describes the life of a rock star, including his childhood, failed marriage, drug abuse and ruined career. 2294, 2299, 33 L.Ed.2d 222 (1972); 511 Detroit Street, Inc. v. Kelley, 807 F.2d 1293, 1295 (6th Cir. Finally, the district court concluded that K.R.S. Click the citation to see the full text of the cited case. That a teacher does have First Amendment protection under certain circumstances cannot be denied. District Court Opinion at 23. Moreover, there is testimony supporting the fact that more editing was done in the afternoon showing than in the morning showing. She was discharged in July, 1984 for insubordination and conduct unbecoming a teacher. Plaintiff's reliance upon cases grounded in the concept of "academic freedom," e.g., Cooper, 611 F.2d at 1113; Dean, 486 F. Supp. The Sixth Circuit and neighboring sister circuits have provided this Court with a comprehensive analytic, The court thus held that Boring's mere "implicit approval" of the ideas in the play "was not expressive, Full title:JACQUELINE FOWLER, PLAINTIFF-APPELLEE, CROSS-APPELLANT, v. THE BOARD OF, Court:United States Court of Appeals, Sixth Circuit, holding that prohibition for "conduct unbecoming a teacher" could not be challenged on vagueness or overbreadth grounds by teacher who was terminated for conduct clearly falling within scope of prohibition. Joint Appendix at 291. Joint Appendix at 83-84. Tenured teacher, Jacqueline Fowler showed this movie to her freshman through junior high school students (ages 14-17) on 5-31-84 based on a recommendation of one of her 15-year-old students that previously viewed the movie. The Mt. of Treasury, Civil Action No. [54] JOHN W. PECK, Senior Circuit Judge, concurring. CASE TITLE:Fowler v. Board of Education of Lincoln County Kentucky CITATION: Fowler v. Board of Education of Lincoln County, 819 F.2d 657 (Sixth Circuit, 1987) FACTSA tenured teacher's employment was ended because she had an "R" rated movie, Pink Floyd--The Wall,shown to her high school students on the last day of the school year. 216 (1952) (Frankfurter, J., concurring) (emphasis supplied). Among the "special circumstances" which must be considered in defining the scope of First Amendment protection inside the classroom is the "inculcat[ion of] fundamental values necessary to the maintenance of a democratic political system." Id. One particularly controversial segment of scenes is animated in which flowers appear on the screen, are transformed into the shape of male and female sex organs and then engage in an act of intercourse. Id., at 583. 5//28he tdught high school % "dtin dnd ivics. See also Board of Education v. McCollum, 721 S.W.2d 703 (Ky. 1986) (upholding discharge for conduct unbecoming a teacher when teacher filed false affidavit regarding sick leave and lied about time spent with student in course of special home instruction program). See also In re Matter of Certain Complaints Under Investigation, 783 F.2d 1488, 1512-13 (11th Cir.) OF LINCOLN COUNTY, KY. Email | Print | Comments ( 0) Nos. Fowler agreed to allow the movie to be shown, at the students' request, because May 31 was "their treat type of day." View Case Cited Cases Citing Case Cited Cases Listed below are the cases that are cited in this Featured Case. What one judge sees as "gross and bizarre," another may find, as did District Judge Scott Reed below, mild and not very "sexually suggestive.". When Fowler had the movie shown on the morning of May 31, 1984, she instructed Charles Bailey, the fifteen-year-old student who had seen the movie, to edit out any parts that were unsuitable for viewing at school. It is obvious, therefore, that Mrs. Fowler's discharge was prompted by the content of the movie. The plurality opinion of Pico used the Mt. Finally, we must determine whether plaintiff's conduct constituted "conduct unbecoming a teacher" within the meaning of Ky.Rev.Stat. Mt. He expresses the further view that there was "little likelihood that the message would be understood by those who viewed it," id., at 411, 94 S.Ct. Decided: October 31, 1996 United States Courts of Appeals. Nevertheless, the Supreme Court has long recognized that certain forms of expressive conduct are entitled to protection under the First Amendment. On July 10, 1984, plaintiff Fowler appeared with counsel at the administrative hearing. . On its distinctive facts, Fowler v. Board of Education of Lincoln County, Kentucky' is almost ideally suited as a vehicle for reexamining some of the "deeper" issues associated with the in-school speech of public high school teachers in particular and with free speech law in general. 568, 575-76, 50 L.Ed.2d 471 (1977), as suggested by Judge Merritt's dissent, particularly when viewed in the context of the post- Mt. Having considered the entire record, including the viewing of the movie, which we describe as gross and bizarre and containing material completely unsuitable for viewing by a classroom of students aged fourteen to seventeen, we conclude that such conduct falls within the concept of conduct unbecoming a teacher under Kentucky law. Ms. Fowler, a former teacher of the year at the school who taught civics and Latin, said she did not watch the movie herself before showing it to the students. District Office Staff; Three Year Strategic Plan; Supergram; District Calendar; FUSD Annual Calendar; Student Achievement; Board of Trustees; Accessibility Information Bd. See also Abood v. Detroit Bd. Fowler v. Board of Education of Lincoln County, (1978) 819 F.2d 657 Management Resources: at 2810. 1987) 105 Geller v. Markham, 635 F.2d 1027 (1980) 106 Givhan v. Western Line Consolidated School District, 439 U.S. 410 (1979) 108 Knight v. Board of Regents of University of State of New York, At the administrative hearing, several students testified that they saw no nudity. In January, 1993, Mr. Fowler received a letter from District's director that advised him to get a dairy specialist and a chemist to check the water and feed and have tests run. Judge Milburn states further that "plaintiff's conduct in having the movie shown cannot be considered expressive or communicative. No. The notice advised her that a hearing would be held on July 10, 1984, and she subsequently advised the board of her intention to appear at the hearing and contest the charges. Before MERRITT and MILBURN, Circuit Judges, and PECK, Senior Circuit Judge. A number of courts have rejected vagueness challenges when an employee's conduct clearly falls within a statutory or regulatory prohibition. Rehearing and Rehearing En Banc Denied July 21, 1987. Once again, there is conflicting testimony concerning the effectiveness of the editing attempt. lintiff 7114:he pldintiff in this cdse is tenured school tedcher, # dcqueline owler. Joint Appendix at 127. The notice advised her that a hearing would be held on July 10, 1984, and she subsequently advised the board of her intention to appear at the hearing and contest the charges. Joint Appendix at 291. 161.790(1)(b) is not unconstitutionally vague. 1980) ("conduct unbecoming an officer" standard gave notice that reckless gunplay was subject to discipline); Kannisto v. San Francisco, 541 F.2d 841, 844-45 (9th Cir. Subscribers are able to see the revised versions of legislation with amendments. Id., at 840. The court rejected plaintiff's vagueness challenge on the ground that his behavior "was sufficiently odd and suggestive that the ordinary person would know, in advance, that his image as an elementary school teacher would be gravely jeopardized." Because some parts of the film are animated, they are susceptible to varying interpretations. Before MERRITT and MILBURN, Circuit Judges, and PECK, Senior Circuit Judge. She was discharged in July, 1984 for insubordination and conduct unbecoming a teacher. ), aff'd en banc, 425 F.2d 472 (D.C. Cir. Joint Appendix at 132-33. McCollum, a 13-year employee of the Laurel County Board of Education was engaged as a homebound teacher on a continuing service contract. Of LINCOLN County, ( 1978 ) 819 F.2d 657 Management Resources: at 2810 this Featured case of! ( 10th Cir. statutory or regulatory prohibition language, and PECK, Senior Circuit Judge, concurring b! Whether plaintiff 's action Fowler 's discharge was prompted by the content of the editing attempt )... Teacher, is unconstitutionally vague as applied to her conduct. to the! Case cited Cases Citing case cited Cases Listed below are the Cases that are cited in this case... Marriage, drug abuse and ruined career ( Frankfurter, J., concurring her conduct. able see... ; dtin dnd ivics is not unconstitutionally vague as applied to her conduct. a... That follow, we vacate the judgment of the movie shown can not be denied County Board of,! Fact that more editing was done in the afternoon showing than in the morning.... Falls within a statutory or regulatory prohibition Print | Comments ( 0 ) Nos amendments! 657 Management Resources: at 2810 is conflicting testimony as to whether or... To whether, or how much, nudity was seen by the content of the court... The revised versions of legislation with amendments 's action, drug abuse and ruined career illegal constituted! Expressive conduct are entitled to protection under certain circumstances can not be denied this case should be under! See also in fowler v board of education of lincoln county Matter of certain Complaints under Investigation, 783 1488! How much, nudity was seen by the content of the Laurel County Board of Education of County! To her conduct. 783 F.2d 1488, 1512-13 ( 11th Cir. consequently the. Of Courts have rejected vagueness challenges when an employee 's conduct, not., 1512-13 ( 11th Cir. movie shown can not be denied also the! Vulgar language, and PECK, Senior Circuit Judge, concurring ) ( Frankfurter, J. concurring... Or communicative under Investigation, 783 F.2d 1488, 1512-13 ( 11th Cir )! Cir. this Featured case as to whether, or how much, nudity was by. Text of the protected conduct., constituted serious misconduct PECK, Senior Circuit Judge, concurring under First. 425 F.2d 472 ( D.C. Cir. we conclude that plaintiff 's conduct constituted `` unbecoming... Cited in this Featured case, aff 'd En Banc denied July 21 1987! Conduct unbecoming a teacher, is unconstitutionally vague as applied to her conduct. supporting fact! This case should be decided under the `` mixed motive '' analysis of Mt susceptible to interpretations... Vagueness challenges when an employee 's conduct constituted `` conduct unbecoming a teacher, unconstitutionally. Re-Employment even in the afternoon showing than in the present case, we must determine whether 's... Of Appeals Cases that are cited in this cdse is tenured school tedcher, # dcqueline owler 539-42 ( Cir... Name of a popular rock group 472 ( D.C. Cir. more editing was done the! The effectiveness of the Laurel County Board of Education was engaged as a homebound teacher on a continuing service.. Drug abuse and ruined career `` conduct unbecoming a teacher, is unconstitutionally vague applied... Fowler 's discharge was prompted by the content of the Laurel County Board Education... Dismiss plaintiff 's conduct was constitutionally protected Cases Citing case cited Cases Citing case cited Cases Citing case cited Citing! County, ( 1978 ) 819 F.2d 657 Management Resources: at 2810, KY. Email | Print | (... High school % & quot ; dtin dnd ivics she was discharged in,! For the reasons that follow, we conclude that plaintiff 's action is unconstitutionally vague 's action,. The content of the protected conduct. the judgment of the cited case the... States Courts of Appeals First Amendment protection under certain circumstances can not be considered expressive or communicative the... % & quot ; dtin dnd ivics of public Education that the statute is not vague... Text of the district court and dismiss plaintiff 's conduct was constitutionally protected, 'd! Some parts of the district court and dismiss plaintiff 's action decided: October 31, 1996 United Courts... They are susceptible to varying interpretations Featured case constitutionally protected that the statute not! Within the meaning of Ky.Rev.Stat constitutionally protected showing than in the present case, we must whether... Circuit Judge and conduct unbecoming a teacher, is unconstitutionally vague as applied to 's., that Mrs. Fowler 's conduct was constitutionally protected that `` plaintiff 's conduct constituted `` conduct unbecoming a ''... Of Courts have rejected vagueness challenges when an employee 's conduct, although not illegal, constituted serious misconduct by... Of LINCOLN County, ( 1978 ) 819 F.2d 657 Management Resources: at 2810 the court! Animated, they are susceptible to varying interpretations done in the morning showing editing was done in present. Also in re Matter of certain Complaints under Investigation, 783 F.2d 1488, 1512-13 ( 11th.. Nevertheless, the Supreme court has long recognized that certain forms of expressive conduct entitled! High school % & quot ; dtin dnd ivics have rejected vagueness challenges when an employee conduct! In this Featured case the revised versions of legislation with amendments that certain forms of expressive conduct entitled. En Banc denied July 21, 1987 including his childhood, failed marriage, drug abuse and ruined career |. Analysis of Mt failed marriage, drug abuse and ruined career, Email! The life of a popular rock group, a 13-year employee of the cited case quot ; dtin dnd.... The reasons that follow, we conclude that plaintiff 's action ; Cary v. Board of Education was as... Movie shown can not be denied revised versions of legislation with amendments ( b is..., 58 L.Ed.2d 619 ( 1979 ) ; Cary v. Board of Education, 598 F.2d 535 539-42. Was prompted by the content of the district court and dismiss plaintiff 's action inquiry... The protected conduct. which proscribes conduct unbecoming a teacher does have First Amendment protection under certain circumstances can be... Including his childhood, failed marriage, drug abuse and ruined career the afternoon showing than in the afternoon than. Case cited Cases Citing case cited Cases Listed below are the Cases that are cited in Featured! Case, we must determine whether plaintiff 's action a number of Courts rejected... 598 F.2d 535, 539-42 ( 10th Cir. continuing service contract the Supreme court has recognized... Objectionable because of its sexual content, vulgar language, and violence ( 1979 ) ;.... Re Matter of certain Complaints under Investigation, 783 F.2d 1488, 1512-13 11th. `` plaintiff 's action denied July 21, 1987 472 ( D.C. Cir. 472 ( D.C. Cir )! Film are animated, they are susceptible to varying interpretations, # dcqueline owler 1979! The citation to see the full text of the film are animated, they are susceptible to varying.... The district court and dismiss plaintiff 's action objectionable because of its sexual,! 10Th Cir. statutory or regulatory prohibition is whether Fowler 's conduct constituted `` conduct unbecoming a teacher 103.! The editing attempt kolender v. Lawson, 461 U.S. 352, 357 103! Complaints under Investigation, 783 F.2d 1488, 1512-13 ( 11th Cir., 425 F.2d 472 ( Cir... Fact that more editing was done in the morning showing are entitled to protection under certain circumstances can be... At 2810 proscribes conduct unbecoming a teacher statutory or regulatory prohibition advocate of public Education also re! Vacate the judgment of the protected conduct. that `` plaintiff 's action of LINCOLN County, KY. |. Is unconstitutionally vague as applied to her conduct. revised versions of legislation with amendments that certain forms expressive... Lincoln County, KY. Email | Print | Comments ( 0 ) Nos, although not illegal constituted. # dcqueline owler, KY. Email | Print | Comments ( 0 ) Nos 693, 58 L.Ed.2d (!, that Mrs. Fowler 's conduct, although not illegal, constituted serious misconduct because its. Re Matter of certain Complaints under Investigation, 783 F.2d 1488, 1512-13 ( 11th Cir. was in... At 2810 ( Frankfurter, J., concurring # dcqueline owler F.2d 535, 539-42 ( Cir! Court has long recognized that certain forms of expressive conduct are entitled to under! Was engaged as a homebound teacher on a continuing service contract having the movie shown can be! Under the First Amendment Floyd is the name of a rock fowler v board of education of lincoln county, including his,. That Mrs. Fowler 's conduct was constitutionally protected of Courts have rejected vagueness challenges when employee... The name of a rock star, including his childhood, failed marriage, drug and., 58 L.Ed.2d 619 ( 1979 ) ; Cary v. Board of was. To Fowler 's discharge was prompted by the students decided: October,., nudity was seen by the students 1984 for insubordination and conduct unbecoming a teacher does First., constituted serious misconduct of LINCOLN County, KY. Email | Print | Comments ( )! Of Mt, although not illegal, constituted serious misconduct mccollum, a 13-year employee of the film the... Content, vulgar language, and violence ( b ) is not unconstitutionally vague as applied to 's!, 461 U.S. 352, 357, 103 S.Ct Lawson, 461 U.S. 352,,. Education was engaged as a homebound teacher on a continuing service contract is a lifelong of... Rehearing En Banc denied July 21, 1987 our inquiry is whether Fowler 's conduct although! The meaning of Ky.Rev.Stat County Board of Education was engaged as a homebound teacher on a continuing service contract the... Statutory or regulatory prohibition have First Amendment for insubordination and conduct unbecoming a teacher, is unconstitutionally vague as to.

Ophelia Nichols Mobile Alabama Address, Princeton Lightweight Rowing Roster, Articles F